| 280 Mysteries We'll Never Get Back #17, “The Case of the Hard Luck Boy” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 19:36 | |
| 280 Mysteries We'll Never Get Back #19, “The Case of the Wagon Master” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 15:53 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #1, “The Case of the Glass of Ginger Ale” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 21:57 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #2, “The Case of Merko’s Grandson” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 20:18 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #3, “The Case of the Balloon Man” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 20:08 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #4, “The Case of the Frightened Witness” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 21:08 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #5, “The Case of Bugs Meany, Detective” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 17:10 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #6, “The Case of the Skunk Ape” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 23:33 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #7, “The Case of Cupid’s Arrow” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 17:32 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #8, “The Case of the Frightened Playboy” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 13:14 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #9, “The Case of the Missing Penny” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 19:29 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #10, “The Case of the Bird Watcher” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 15:20 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #11, "The Case of the Stolen Pigs” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 16:00 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #12, “The Case of the Five Clues” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 17:24 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #13, “The Case of the Foot Warmers” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 16:10 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #14, “The Case of the Hungry Hitchhiker” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 15:22 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #15, "The Case of the Missing Watch Goose” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 21:52 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #16, “The Case of the Wounded Dog” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 19:16 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #18, “The Case of the Stolen Confederate Stamps” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 18:10 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #35, "The Case of the Mysterious Thief” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson with Craig Finn | | | 51:52 | |
| 280 Mysteries We’ll Never Get Back #37, “The Case of the Carousel Horse” | Conor Lastowka, Michael J. Nelson & Ken Jennings | | | 54:34 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #0, “A Book We’re Probably Going to Hate” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 26:59 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #1, “Ready Player One #1: A Miniseries About a Housecoat” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:01:59 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #2, “Ready Player One #2: A List and a Lich” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:02:35 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #3, “Ready Player One #3: Ducks and Hairy Knuckled Chucks” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:12:45 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #4, “Ready Player One #4: Delightful 80’s References and Several Hundred Dead Children!” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:12:53 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #5, “Ready Player One #5: Several Discreet Openings” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:17:23 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #6, “Ready Player One #6: Rush for a Change of Atmosphere” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:21:19 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #7, “Ready Player One #7: 1973 Was My Favorite Year in the 80s” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:20:14 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #8, “Ready Player One #8: 1980s Reference” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:42:01 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #9, “Armada #1” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 30:14 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #10, “Armada #2: What Have We Done?” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:19:24 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #11, “Armada #3: Insanely Hot (But Relateable) Moms” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:27:07 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #12, “Armada #4: The Hot Geek Girl Laughed at My Episode Title” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:35:22 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #13, “Armada #5: Or as It Came to Be Known, Episode 13” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:38:09 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #14, “Armada #6: A General Uses the Term Snackage” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:48:33 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #15, “Armada #7: Some Light, Pre-Apocalypse Boning” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:29:49 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #16, “Armada #8: And Then All That Happened, the End” | Conor Lastowka and Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:49:11 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #17, “We’ll Do It Live… Or Will We?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:49:49 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #18, “A Crummy Commercial” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 9:31 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #19, “The Eye of Argon” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 33:37 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #20, “The Eye of Argon #1: Hope You Like Adjectives!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:40:23 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #21, “The Eye of Argon #2: Mo’ Shamen, Maw Problems” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:36:06 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #22, “Book Four Reveal!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 25:09 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #23, “TekWar #1: Plasepisode Plastwenty Plasthree” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:45:16 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #24, “TekWar #2: ¡El Pelo Hinchable!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:51:21 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #25, “TekWar #3: Meetings About Sonny Hokori” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:44:21 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #26, “TekWar #4: Located in the Exact Center of your Podcast App” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:33:48 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #27, “TekWar #5: A Heavy Airquotes Simple Plan” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:39:43 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #28, “TekWar #6: Al’s House of Lucite” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:51:52 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #29, “Tekwar #7: What the Hell Was That?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:17:43 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #30, “Manifesto in Book Form” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 37:05 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #31, “The Forensic Certified Public Accountant and the Cremated 64-SQUARES Financial Statements #1: I, Titus Uno” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:41:33 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #32, “The Forensic Certified Public Accountant and the Cremated 64-SQUARES Financial Statements #2: Ctrl-V, Repeat” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:03:43 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #33, “The Forensic Certified Public Accountant and the Cremated 64-SQUARES Financial Statements #3: Checkmate” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:12:35 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #34, “A 160 Page Self-Own” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 37:56 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #35, “Bob Honey Who Just Do Stuff #1: Uh… OK?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:55:57 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #36, “Bob Honey Who Just Do Stuff #2: We’re Baffled by the Cherry Water” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:46:39 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #37, “Bob Honey Who Just Do Stuff #3: I Laugh a lot When I Write” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:30:41 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #38, “Bob Honey Who Just Do Stuff #4: 160 Pages We’ll Never Get Back” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:42:13 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #39, “Broken Camera Blues” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 27:42 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #40, “Book Number Seven” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 30:59 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #41, “The Mister #1: Handsome Buttocks” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:54:37 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #42, “The Mister #2: Not A Groin Was Stirring” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:56:48 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #43, “The Mister #3: Music for your what now?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:54:12 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #44, “The Mister #4: Male Tasting Fingers” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:57:19 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #45, “The Mister #5: Wherefore Art Thou, Bleriana?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:10:38 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #46, “The Mister #6: Bleriana’s Bucket” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:54:14 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #47, “The Mister #7: So do Albanian cars have seatbelts or what?” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:11:55 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #48, “Trucking Through Time #1” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:06:22 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #49, “Trucking Through Time #2: A Bad Day for the Home Team” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:04:00 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #50, “Trucking Through Time #3: Arthur 'Three Socks' Jackson” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:00:32 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #51, “Trucking Through Time #4: Grandpa, No!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:16:59 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #52, “Trucking Through Time #5: Hold Onto Your Buckskins” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:13:51 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #53, “Trucking Through Time #6: Seven Days of Mystery, Drama, Excitement, Compassion, Horror, and Romance” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:19:45 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #54, “Book 9” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 29:10 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #55, “The Lair of the White Worm #1: A Very Special Mongoose” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:26:35 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #56, “The Lair of the White Worm #2: For the Benefit of Evil Bird Kite” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:58:28 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #57, “The Lair of the White Worm #3: Well Hung Doors” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:04:26 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #58, “The Lair of the White Worm #4: China Worm Sunflower” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:06:47 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #59, “Book 10” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 29:07 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #60, “Shadow Moon #1: This Podcast is now named Thorn Drumheller” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:00:38 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #61, “Shadow Moon #2: Don’t Put Ketchup on your Death Dog” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:00:03 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #62, “Shadow Moon #3: Llamacorn sez, Well coat my meat in peanut sauce, it’s a new ep!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:49:04 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #63, “Shadow Moon #4: Shadow Moon: Episoude the Fourth” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:07:42 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #64, “Shadow Moon #5: Willow Loves Willow” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:58:07 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #65, “Shadow Moon #6: Pig Girl Wrecks the Can” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:06:45 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #66, “Shadow Moon #7: We Come to Bury Burys” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:09:06 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #67, “Shadow Moon #8: The Worst Book We’ve Ever Read” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:56:55 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #67.5, “Book 11 Announcement” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 8:51 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #68, “Moon People #1: Still Tippin’ on 222s” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:12:27 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #69, “Moon People #2: I Seen All Good People” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:15:45 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #70, “Moon People #3: Potato Pudding and Space Catalogs” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:19:45 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #71, “Digital Fortress #1: If “Bizarre Foods” Went Horny” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:01:52 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #72, “Digital Fortress #2: Bobby Digital in Stereo” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:15:04 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #73, “Digital Fortress #3: Enter Halite” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:12:09 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #74, “Digital Fortress #4: Chapters! We Got Yer Chapters!” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:08:57 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #75, “Digital Fortress #5: Cuz My Beeper Kept Beepin’” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:22:35 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #76, “Digital Fortress #6: The Sad End of Rafael de la Maza” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 1:57:27 | |
| 372 Pages We'll Never Get Back #77, “Digital Fortress #7: Man. Silhouette. LEGEND.” | Conor Lastowka & Michael J. Nelson | | | 2:36:52 | |