| All the Wasted Time | Carolee Carmello & Brent Carver | | | 4:43 | |
| All the Wasted Time | Brent Carver & Carolee Carmello | | | 4:41 | |
| Anytime (I Am There) | Carolee Carmello | | | 4:48 | |
| At the Prom / Ah, Maien Zeit! / Tom (Scene Five: The Young Wife and the Husband) | Carolee Carmello, Dennis Parlato | | | 6:02 | |
| Boom! Shout! Reprise! | Jason Howland, Nathan Tysen, Carolee Carmello, Jessica Keenan Wynn& Original Cast of A Killer Party | | | 1:27 | |
| Can This Be Love? | Carolee Carmello | | | 3:09 | |
| Circus of Your Dreams | Carolee Carmello, Kelsey Grammer & Teal Wicks | | | 4:31 | |
| Finale | Aidan Gemme, Alex Dreier, Carolee Carmello, Christopher Paul Richards, Matthew Morrison & Sawyer Nunes | | | 2:49 | |
| Finale Ultimo | Carolee Carmello | | | 2:35 | |
| Fine and Dandy | Carolee Carmello / Mario Cantone | | | 4:14 | |
| Goodbye/Boom Boom | Carolee Carmello / Keith Byron Kirk | | | 7:32 | |
| Let's Go Eat Worms in the Garden | Gavin Creel / Carolee Carmello | | | 2:45 | |
| Mister Choi & Madame G | Carolee Carmello / Christian Borle / Keith Byron Kirk | | | 3:51 | |
| Neverland (reprise) | Aidan Gemme, Alex Dreier, Carolee Carmello, Christopher Paul Richards, Laura Michelle Kelly, Matthew Morrison & Sawyer Nunes | | | 7:22 | |
| Nobody Breaks My Heart | Carolee Carmello | | | 4:08 | |
| Passover | Carolee Carmello | | | 4:13 | |
| Peggy Hewitt & Mysty del Giorno | Carolee Carmello / Christian Borle | | | 2:50 | |
| Sleuth in Duluth | Jason Howland, Nathan Tysen, Carolee Carmello& Original Cast of A Killer Party | | | 1:47 | |
| Sleuth in Duluth (Reprise) | Jason Howland, Nathan Tysen, Carolee Carmello, Jessica Keenan Wynn& Original Cast of A Killer Party | | | 1:39 | |
| Story of My Life (Scene Four: The College Boy and the Young Wife) | Carolee Carmello, Michael Park | | | 6:23 | |
| The Memory of Tonight (Arthur! The Musical) | Carolee Carmello, Gregg Edelman | | | 4:16 | |
