| A Christmas Song (reprise) | Rachel Bloom, Max Charles, Larry Dorf, Mark Hamill, Rachael MacFarlane, Kate Micucci, Rachel Ramras & Kevin Shinick with Jim Parsons | | | 3:30 | |
| Aerobics Song | Max Charles & Chris Parnell | | | 0:49 | |
| Firsts Song | Greg Whipple, Chris Parnell & Max Charles | | | 0:43 | |
| I’ll Believe in You | Max Charles & Rachael MacFarlane | | | 2:08 | |
| Laika Rap | Max Charles & Chris Parnell | | | 0:45 | |
| Sparklejollytwinklejingley | Max Charles, Rachael MacFarlane & Jim Parsons | | | 1:47 | |
| Taco Pudding | Max Charles & Chris Parnell | | | 0:35 | |
| The Story of Buddy the Elf | Fred Armisen, Edward Asner, Rachel Bloom, Max Charles, Larry Dorf, Gilbert Gottfried, Mark Hamill, Steve Higgins, Rachael MacFarlane, Kate Micucci, Jim Parsons, Rachel Ramras & Kevin Shinick | | | 2:32 | |
| There Is a Santa Claus | Max Charles & Rachael MacFarlane | | | 1:17 | |
| Wedding Day | Max Charles, Chris Parnell & Da'Vine Joy Randolph | | | 1:15 | |
