This page has not been reviewed by our documentation team (more info).

Duplicate Releases are entries in the database where the same release has been added or imported from FreeDB multiple times.

On the SiteMenu, under Edit the Data -> Suggestions, there is a DuplicateReleasesReport that lists many suspected duplicates.

There are a number of cases where similar releases are not duplicates:

  • Different releases may have additional (bonus) tracks added.

  • Different releases may have different versions (longer, shorter, or otherwise changed) of certain tracks.

  • A release may be present multiple times: both with the original titles and with titles translated or transliterated into (an) other language(s). If these duplicates were never really released but only in the database to have a different representation, they are called VirtualDuplicateReleases.

  • A release may be re-released as a RemasteredRelease, where the track listing and times are the same, but the music sounds different. (But conversely, if it's a ReReleasedButNotRemasteredRelease, it is ok to enter a MergeReleasesEdit).

    • This is a fuzzy case; remastering may not change the audio of the track that significantly. As a rule of thumb, if the remastered and original versions share a significant number of TRMs, there is no effective difference between the releases, and they should be considered duplicates. @alex

      I don't think it's particularly fuzzy. If the vinyl, minidisc, and cassette releases can be combined with the CD release (that has the same number/order of tracks, then a separate 'remaster' CD is a bit odd. There should maybe be a tickbox for 'remastered' attached to a specific release date, but it's of very little importance in my opinion. -- bawjaws

There are or should be entries describing these under StyleGuidelines and other places (InterNationalization?).


CategoryEditing Stub

 
Creative Commons EFF GPL LGPL This material is Open Knowledge Valid XHTML 1.1 Valid CSS 2.0
Original Design|vacubomb.com Contact details Server version: RELEASE-20071014